[Yeah, yeah, guns are bad, Odile. That's why it's a weapon. He's not here to make friends with it.]

You can't seriously still think that's actually him after all that?!

[Stan doesn't even know him that well and he's still sure that's not the real Siffrin. Mostly from how Loop's reacted to things and the little he's been told about the real deal, but the point still stands. Even people who do know Siffrin are starting to see the cracks, and filling in the gaps Stan couldn't explain alone.]

Besides, what would YOU do, huh?! If it was the other way around and it looked like Dipper murdered Siffrin? Would you hold back if everything was pointed at him?

[There's no way she'd be all "this doesn't warrant murder" if Siffrin was the one who'd died, Stan's sure of it.]