[ Neither, but he's not going to elaborate on that now. Maybe he'll tell him about his ability after he's had a few days to adjust. ]
My guess is that they just haven't been revived yet. I'm not sure. Death isn't really final since the god is using us like chewtoys. Not that it's without consequence. Your memory was probably the price this time.
[ Pavlova doesn't understand why some deaths are more final than others, why some take longer to revive. It feels abitrary, only this time Pure Vanilla's lost all memory of before, like a hard reset. Maybe so everyone has to suffer watching Pure Vanilla make the same mistakes all over again.
That seems like something the Forest would do. Whatever hurts the most. ]
( To think that others have experienced death, only to return from it. As sorrowful as death can be, there's something cruel about breaking that natural cycle, too.
The last thing he wants is for anyone to experience something like that more than once. )
... Thank you, truly. You have done a great kindness by explaining as much as you have.
( There's a brief pause on his end before he speaks again. )
At one point in time, I was without my memory, much like now. While the reason may be different, perhaps there can be a way to regain what was once lost.
Both Shadow Milk and Miss Lily talk a lot about you, so I guess I'm curious.
[ "Pure Vanilla would adore you," they'd said. He doubted that.
As far as the memories go... If only it were so easy. He doubts that he will ever get those memories back. That's the whole point of a consequence, after all. That said, the boy taps his shoe thoughtfully against the earth. ]
Well, even if you don't, I can probably tell you a few things to fill in the gaps. Being aware of it is better than nothing.
Oh, my... I do hope that I live up to any kind words they have to offer.
( He offers a smile, bright and warm. )
Any friend of White Lily's is a friend of mine, as well. I'm thankful that we ran into one another so quickly, despite the circumstances.
( Though, admittedly... Shadow Milk and Pure Vanilla's interactions have been rather tense, but he's been hoping for that to change. )
Before we continue, shall I go try to find something warm for the both of us to drink? Even if we do not go inside, doing this much will help fight the chill in the air.
[ "Friend" seemed at once like both an overestimation and an underestimation of their relationship. He really doesn't know how to explain it without talking about his relation to Shadow Milk and Shadow Milk's relationship with White lily from there.
For once he could identify this as firmly not his place to talk about ]
It was pretty much only kind words. You're a very loved person.
[ His heart proves as much with a glance. Covered in threads, so many friends and loved ones... but he won't look too close for now. ]
Sure! The inn's just south of here, and there's a café a bit more south from there.
[ If they have some time they might as well. He's very curious about Pure Vanilla anyway. He offers the man a hand to help lead the way. ]
So you don't remember being here before. What's the last thing you do remember, then?
( Though, if it's with Shadow Milk as well... He'd be surprised. Pleasantly so, but it's definitely a dramatic change. )
Please, lead the way. I shall follow behind you.
( What he remembers last... He falls silent for a moment. )
... The last thing I remember is making plans to travel back to Crispia. If I had arrived to this world any time before then, I'm afraid that there are no gaps in my memory. However, Shadow Milk Cookie and I were not on the best of terms at that time.
Situations tend to change when you can't run from things.
[ The ittiest bittiest jab at his father, there. It's affectionate, though.
He'll lead the way out of the forested area into the clearing. It let them out just behind the inn, so he leads them around the side. ]
I dunno if you're going to be living with Shadow Milk, Miss Lily and I, but if not, the Inn here is probably where you'll be staying for a bit. The Café is right over there.
[ He gestures over at it with his free hand. Up to him which they go to. Pavlova doesn't seem to mind. ]
Hmm... that was probably around the same time I was taken here? Maybe a little earlier or later? Hollyberry Cookie was escaping from the Garden and all.
[ He gives a little shrug ]
Well, from what I can tell, Shadow Milk came from roughly the same point in time, he's just been here with you and the others for... a while.
[ He can't recall if he ever actually asked. He was kind of frazzled when he got here. ]
( Perhaps so, but if Shadow Milk truly took the offer that Pure Vanilla was giving to him, then how could he not feel overjoyed? He may have lied to him in order to save his friends, but that didn't change the fact that he wanted so much to help ease Shadow Milk's loneliness.
He doesn't really want to impose on either of them, though staying close to his fellow cookies does sound rather nice in a situation that seems so new... )
A garden? I admit that it has been a while since I have last spoken to Hollyberry Cookie, but I am glad that you were given the chance to meet her! She has been a dear friend of mine for a long time. If there is anyone who can inspire another's strength, it is her.
( He moves to head to the cafe. At the least, going somewhere warm would be better for the both of them. )
I see... If that is the case, then time here is far different than that of Earthbread's.
The Garden of Sweet Delights~ You're looking at one of Eternal Sugar Cookie's closest subordinates.
[ Well, he's her son. But he felt more like a lackey after her fall, so it's not entirely a lie. It's just not the whole truth.
This of course does also mean that he was in fact not helping Hollyberry Cookie. So what Pure Vanilla just said was a little awkward. ]
... Right. I think she just saw me as a brat.
[ At very least she shot down his observations at every opportunity. Whether that was because she didn't want to confront what he was saying or she just flat out disliked him, he's not sure. ]
[ he doesn't let that stop him from heading to the café with him, though. He's keeping an eye on Pure Vanilla's reaction. The café is quite warm though. Pavlova nudges him at one of the tables. ]
Yeah, it's really strange. I'm guessing it makes sense because of the trip that some would arrive before others... Oh! Do you want tea? Or maybe hot chocolate?
[ Lily and Shadow Milk are both tea people to the point he just kind of assumes Pure Vanilla is also a tea guy. ]
I am certain that it was not that. Once Hollyberry Cookie has a goal in mind, she... can be rather stubborn. She's known well for her passion.
( To say the least. It's something that he's come to know very well over the years, but he sounds fond. Hollyberry is one of his most precious friends.
But, Eternal Sugar Cookie... One of the beast cookies, perhaps? If that was the case, then Hollyberry Cookie had her hands full just as he did. However, he has faith that Hollyberry made it through any trials that she ended up facing.
Pure Vanilla takes a seat, though he hesitates at the offer. )
If you wold like to, I would be thankful for tea. Though, will you allow me to treat you to something similar in return when I'm able to?
[ Stubborn is a way to put it but he's still all but certain she hated him.
Then again he's convinced most of the ancients secretly have it out for him. He holds himself a bit tense. ]
You're already thinking about paying me back? It's not that big a deal~
[ Deftly avoiding the question as he heads up to the counter. Now, he's not sure what Pure Vanilla's favorite is, but he does know what kinds Shadow Milk and Lily kept on hand, and from reading his father he knew that those were kinds he'll drink. It's ordered and Pavlova is returning to the table with it not long later. ]
( He'd never ask for anyone to return kindness to him, but he's a big believer in doing that on his end. It's alright if Pavlova avoids his question now. It's something they can return to later. )
Have you been staying with Shadow Milk Cookie during your time here?
( There's much he wants to know about this place, but knowing more about his fellow cookies isn't something he'd pass up, either. )
( There's surprise in his tone when he asks, tilting his head a little. So much of this has been so much to take in... He has much to catch up on, and he's certain that White Lily will also fill him on everything that's transpired in his absence. )
Despite everything, it sounds as though this world has had some blessings in disguise, too. I am glad that you've been able to experience something positive.
It sounds as though they found common ground in their situation. I am grateful for that. Shadow Milk Cookie may not admit this, but... I believe that he yearned for a true friend.
( And White Lily is someone who is perfect for that. Bias aside, he knows how much she treasures others. )
One can find a home, even in times of misfortune. Sometimes, it's the company around you that can create that.
( He stops for a moment then, looking up from his tea. With the words that he's saying, it's simple enough to know exactly who he's referring to. But, how could it not be a shock? )
... Father? Do you mean-- Shadow Milk Cookie?
( So, he shared his dough with someone...? Perhaps it shouldn't be a surprise. Much of the history that the beasts share remains a mystery. )
Dad didn't really talk about me much, I think. I lived with my mother.
[ It wouldn't surprise him if Shadow Milk completely forgot he existed until he visited the Garden again, honestly. From what Pavlova can tell, he's been very busy. ]
The times I did meet with Shadow Milk Cookie wasn't... exactly ones for normal conversation, however being here has proven to be a blessing in disguise.
I'm grateful that we have the chance to speak now.
( He raises a cup to his lips in thought. )
The better question may be, what are you comfortable with saying?
[ This is SO weird. Pavlova tilts his head slightly, lips pursed. ]
I mean sure, but it's hard to figure out where to start when you don't ask questions...
[ he tries to shake off the nerves and awkwardness- his father likes this guy, and everyone he hears talk about him always glows about how kind he is. May as well go for it. ]
Well, I guess... My mother is Eternal Sugar Cookie, but that was probably pretty obvious. I like to read, and I love love! Hollyberry Cookie considered me nosy for it, but like, helping people find their happiness is my job. I'm also a really good archer, most people wouldn't be able to draw the string on my bow.
Hmmm, you would think, but not always. You've felt it many times yourself. Love hurts just as much, giving as much as it takes. Some of the most gut-wrenching, horrible things are fueled by love! Lives torn apart because someone loved something too much! Oh, I've seen all of it before.
[ His smile is so serene despite the turn of the conversation ]
I had many people come to me in the garden seeking out their happiness, but it wasn't always granted quite as expected.
no subject
My guess is that they just haven't been revived yet. I'm not sure. Death isn't really final since the god is using us like chewtoys. Not that it's without consequence. Your memory was probably the price this time.
[ Pavlova doesn't understand why some deaths are more final than others, why some take longer to revive. It feels abitrary, only this time Pure Vanilla's lost all memory of before, like a hard reset. Maybe so everyone has to suffer watching Pure Vanilla make the same mistakes all over again.
That seems like something the Forest would do. Whatever hurts the most. ]
no subject
The last thing he wants is for anyone to experience something like that more than once. )
... Thank you, truly. You have done a great kindness by explaining as much as you have.
( There's a brief pause on his end before he speaks again. )
At one point in time, I was without my memory, much like now. While the reason may be different, perhaps there can be a way to regain what was once lost.
no subject
[ "Pure Vanilla would adore you," they'd said. He doubted that.
As far as the memories go... If only it were so easy. He doubts that he will ever get those memories back. That's the whole point of a consequence, after all. That said, the boy taps his shoe thoughtfully against the earth. ]
Well, even if you don't, I can probably tell you a few things to fill in the gaps. Being aware of it is better than nothing.
no subject
( He offers a smile, bright and warm. )
Any friend of White Lily's is a friend of mine, as well. I'm thankful that we ran into one another so quickly, despite the circumstances.
( Though, admittedly... Shadow Milk and Pure Vanilla's interactions have been rather tense, but he's been hoping for that to change. )
Before we continue, shall I go try to find something warm for the both of us to drink? Even if we do not go inside, doing this much will help fight the chill in the air.
no subject
For once he could identify this as firmly not his place to talk about ]
It was pretty much only kind words. You're a very loved person.
[ His heart proves as much with a glance. Covered in threads, so many friends and loved ones... but he won't look too close for now. ]
Sure! The inn's just south of here, and there's a café a bit more south from there.
[ If they have some time they might as well. He's very curious about Pure Vanilla anyway. He offers the man a hand to help lead the way. ]
So you don't remember being here before. What's the last thing you do remember, then?
no subject
( Though, if it's with Shadow Milk as well... He'd be surprised. Pleasantly so, but it's definitely a dramatic change. )
Please, lead the way. I shall follow behind you.
( What he remembers last... He falls silent for a moment. )
... The last thing I remember is making plans to travel back to Crispia. If I had arrived to this world any time before then, I'm afraid that there are no gaps in my memory. However, Shadow Milk Cookie and I were not on the best of terms at that time.
no subject
[ The ittiest bittiest jab at his father, there. It's affectionate, though.
He'll lead the way out of the forested area into the clearing. It let them out just behind the inn, so he leads them around the side. ]
I dunno if you're going to be living with Shadow Milk, Miss Lily and I, but if not, the Inn here is probably where you'll be staying for a bit. The Café is right over there.
[ He gestures over at it with his free hand. Up to him which they go to. Pavlova doesn't seem to mind. ]
Hmm... that was probably around the same time I was taken here? Maybe a little earlier or later? Hollyberry Cookie was escaping from the Garden and all.
[ He gives a little shrug ]
Well, from what I can tell, Shadow Milk came from roughly the same point in time, he's just been here with you and the others for... a while.
[ He can't recall if he ever actually asked. He was kind of frazzled when he got here. ]
no subject
He doesn't really want to impose on either of them, though staying close to his fellow cookies does sound rather nice in a situation that seems so new... )
A garden? I admit that it has been a while since I have last spoken to Hollyberry Cookie, but I am glad that you were given the chance to meet her! She has been a dear friend of mine for a long time. If there is anyone who can inspire another's strength, it is her.
( He moves to head to the cafe. At the least, going somewhere warm would be better for the both of them. )
I see... If that is the case, then time here is far different than that of Earthbread's.
no subject
[ Well, he's her son. But he felt more like a lackey after her fall, so it's not entirely a lie. It's just not the whole truth.
This of course does also mean that he was in fact not helping Hollyberry Cookie. So what Pure Vanilla just said was a little awkward. ]
... Right. I think she just saw me as a brat.
[ At very least she shot down his observations at every opportunity. Whether that was because she didn't want to confront what he was saying or she just flat out disliked him, he's not sure. ]
[ he doesn't let that stop him from heading to the café with him, though. He's keeping an eye on Pure Vanilla's reaction. The café is quite warm though. Pavlova nudges him at one of the tables. ]
Yeah, it's really strange. I'm guessing it makes sense because of the trip that some would arrive before others... Oh! Do you want tea? Or maybe hot chocolate?
[ Lily and Shadow Milk are both tea people to the point he just kind of assumes Pure Vanilla is also a tea guy. ]
no subject
( To say the least. It's something that he's come to know very well over the years, but he sounds fond. Hollyberry is one of his most precious friends.
But, Eternal Sugar Cookie... One of the beast cookies, perhaps? If that was the case, then Hollyberry Cookie had her hands full just as he did. However, he has faith that Hollyberry made it through any trials that she ended up facing.
Pure Vanilla takes a seat, though he hesitates at the offer. )
If you wold like to, I would be thankful for tea. Though, will you allow me to treat you to something similar in return when I'm able to?
no subject
Then again he's convinced most of the ancients secretly have it out for him. He holds himself a bit tense. ]
You're already thinking about paying me back? It's not that big a deal~
[ Deftly avoiding the question as he heads up to the counter. Now, he's not sure what Pure Vanilla's favorite is, but he does know what kinds Shadow Milk and Lily kept on hand, and from reading his father he knew that those were kinds he'll drink. It's ordered and Pavlova is returning to the table with it not long later. ]
Are there other things you want to know?
no subject
( He'd never ask for anyone to return kindness to him, but he's a big believer in doing that on his end. It's alright if Pavlova avoids his question now. It's something they can return to later. )
Have you been staying with Shadow Milk Cookie during your time here?
( There's much he wants to know about this place, but knowing more about his fellow cookies isn't something he'd pass up, either. )
no subject
[ --because he's Shadow Milk's son, but that's not a revelation to be had now. He's sure his father would like dropping that on him much more. ]
It's been nice. I never lived in a house before.
no subject
( There's surprise in his tone when he asks, tilting his head a little. So much of this has been so much to take in... He has much to catch up on, and he's certain that White Lily will also fill him on everything that's transpired in his absence. )
Despite everything, it sounds as though this world has had some blessings in disguise, too. I am glad that you've been able to experience something positive.
no subject
[ He gives a little shrug. He could give a play by play of their relationship and how it progressed but he doesn't really want to right now. ]
I'm sure you'll like it here in the down time between the horrors. It's not that bad day to day.
no subject
( And White Lily is someone who is perfect for that. Bias aside, he knows how much she treasures others. )
One can find a home, even in times of misfortune. Sometimes, it's the company around you that can create that.
no subject
[ Just says that. Not like PV didn't know already. ]
I wonder sometimes if it would have helped if I could have visited him at the spire, but it probably wouldn't have.
[ He was barely old enough to be a good conversation partner, let alone understand most of what his father would have wanted to talk about.
Besides as a parent, he probably didn't want to push that onto his child.
He can't help feeling like it was his fault though, for not trying harder. He felt that way about his mother too. ]
no subject
... Father? Do you mean-- Shadow Milk Cookie?
( So, he shared his dough with someone...? Perhaps it shouldn't be a surprise. Much of the history that the beasts share remains a mystery. )
no subject
Uhh. Surprise?
[ He's able to pull a shadow milk and use magic to pop some confetti for effect. Like father like son. ]
no subject
... It is surprising that we have only just met now, but it's a pleasure all the same.
Please, if you're alright with it... I'd be happy to hear more about you.
no subject
[ It wouldn't surprise him if Shadow Milk completely forgot he existed until he visited the Garden again, honestly. From what Pavlova can tell, he's been very busy. ]
I guess I don't mind. What do you want to know?
no subject
I'm grateful that we have the chance to speak now.
( He raises a cup to his lips in thought. )
The better question may be, what are you comfortable with saying?
no subject
I mean sure, but it's hard to figure out where to start when you don't ask questions...
[ he tries to shake off the nerves and awkwardness- his father likes this guy, and everyone he hears talk about him always glows about how kind he is. May as well go for it. ]
Well, I guess... My mother is Eternal Sugar Cookie, but that was probably pretty obvious. I like to read, and I love love! Hollyberry Cookie considered me nosy for it, but like, helping people find their happiness is my job. I'm also a really good archer, most people wouldn't be able to draw the string on my bow.
no subject
( It's something he's sought after for a long time. Even though he's failed in the past, it's inspiring that others share that very dream. )
Though, love and happiness go hand-in-hand, don't they?
no subject
[ His smile is so serene despite the turn of the conversation ]
I had many people come to me in the garden seeking out their happiness, but it wasn't always granted quite as expected.
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)